Dear potential Home seeker,
Would like to share with you and keep on record for your use these random queries of one who is not opposed to being a home seeker.
These questions and replies are an assorted set from the book titled Talks with Sri Ramana Maharshi.
(They represent some of the generally posed questions by every mind that resists the idea of change but is willing to take a look at the options available once the need to change is grasped, even if superficially, or if stagnation within is recognized.)
When asked, ‘What is the purpose of creation?’ His reply comes ‘It is to give rise to this question; investigate the answer to this question, and finally abide in the supreme or rather the primal source of all, including the Self. The investigation will resolve itself into the quest for the Self and cease only after the non-self is sifted away and the Self is realized in its purity and glory.
1. What should I do with myself?
Seek your ‘Self’ and identify with it.
2. What is the way to proceed from here?
Question from where does the illusion of being an individual arise. Question its beginning, its very origin, if it has any.
3. You told me to look in, now you say when you look out look from within, why and how should I do it?
The world is in you. You are not in the world. When you look out know what you see is a figment of your imagination. It is ethereal like a dream.
4. If the self is realized will there be normal life or not?
Whose normal life are you asking about? For the man on the stair who was not there? Intense longing to be relieved from the burdensome individuality will not pose this question.
5. My one question remains unanswered even after reading or knowing much, i.e., why is there still thoughts or mental activity going on within me in spite of having had experiences of my being the spirit, the ungraspable being through the experience of Samadhi?
Without such earnestness to seek your source as a gateway to freedom and as long as there remains a trace of desire and fear, the individuality continues to safeguard its stake due to its inability to meet the high expectations of the teacher or faith.
6. I still don’t understand.
Sincere efforts to understand will be rewarded.
7. Is jnana the same as arudha, saktipata etc?
Yes, it is so.
8. Is there any difference between Bhakti and jnana?
There is none. Jnana is the eternal, unbroken state full of love for the Self as the Self. It implies Bhakti and here the God is seen to be the Self.
9. Will work continue or not?
Again whose? The individual’s? Did you not wish the man on the stair that was not there to go away?
10. Why can’t we speak to Iswara in the same way as we speak to each other?
It requires purity and strength of mind and practice. Such manifestations are as real as your own reality. The objects seen bear a relation to the state of the seer (refer to your three natural states of waking, dream and sleep). The same applies to the vision of God. (Story of Namdev – Jnandev,Gora Kumbhar, and the great Gorakhnath)
11. What is Self surrender (Saranaagati)?(Pg 384, Talks)
The ego submits only when it recognizes a Higher Power, the true nature of the ‘Self’. Such recognition is surrender, submission or self control.
12. How can the mind be brought under control?
By seeking its source so that it may disappear or surrender, that it may be struck down.
13. It slips from my control!
Bring it back and turn it inward. That is enough. Put in effort and persevere.
14. Alternately, can I merely resign to the guiding power and do nothing else?
That is the best thing to do. The train takes you and your luggage whether you carry it or put it down. Do not pose as doer ever.
15. Can the teacher substantially transfer spirituality to the student or not ( Like Swami Vivekananda and others received from Sri Ramakrishna or their masters)?
Here transfer means eradicating the seeming individuality of the student. There is no substance to be transferred. The student was not once something then made into another but his imagination of individuality is quashed. (Like the ‘Man upon the stair’)
16. A Sadguru is necessary to guide me to understand it. I want a visible guru.
The Sadguru is within. The visible guru says that He is within.
17. What is diksha or initiation?
The books speak of various dikshas – Sparsha, Hastha and Nayana, and of rites containing fire, water and mantra etc.
If the individual is sought he is nowhere to be found. When the Lord Dakshinamurthi sat silently the doubts of the seekers who sought him were dispelled which means they lost their individual identities and had the experience of oneness or unity. This is what we term Jnana.( Ironically, Maya offered us the faculty of speech through Sound, Word and Tongue to express what can be done through silence.)
18. But when will this understanding come about. I have spent years toiling and longing for it?
The question of Time is a whole subject in itself to be dealt with. To answer the question – the work proceeding within is not apparent. Remain silent both by mind and speech. Silence is the most potent form of work.
19. Does the guru in body merit as much as the Guru of spirit like say Dakshinamurti?
When you identify yourself with your body this kind of question arises. The seeker is to realize that he is not an individual within an exclusive body.
20. Do you mean to say that both dream and waking creations are illusory?
Yes, the difference is only apparent and not real from the standpoint of the Absolute.
21. Is God with form or without? Which is better – idol worship or formless worship?
There is no use discussing the form or formlessness of God without understanding whether you yourself have a form or not. Seek that first, the second part will be answered automatically.
Every attribute even that of formlessness is a notion i.e. saguna. If you so prefer the attributeless first find out your true nature.